An independent ingredient and price comparison. We don't sell products. Buy buttons are affiliate links.Independent comparison. Buy buttons are affiliate links.
Two products from the same category (Toners) side by side: the verdict, eight ingredient-list checks, key ingredients by position, and prices by store. Shared key ingredients: Panthenol (B5), Salicylic acid (BHA), and AHA acids.
We don't name a winner. This page puts the lists and prices side by side, and the choice is yours.
Differences at a glance
The lowest price is £19.67 (about €23.41) for Heartleaf Skin Toner Pads and £10.06 (about €11.97) for AHA/BHA Clarifying Treatment Toner.
Essential-oil-free: yes for AHA/BHA Clarifying Treatment Toner, no for Heartleaf Skin Toner Pads.
Madecassoside is ingredient no. 22 in Heartleaf Skin Toner Pads and is not in the list for AHA/BHA Clarifying Treatment Toner.
Hyaluronic acid is ingredient no. 14 in Heartleaf Skin Toner Pads and is not in the list for AHA/BHA Clarifying Treatment Toner.
Houttuynia cordata is ingredient no. 1 in Heartleaf Skin Toner Pads and is not in the list for AHA/BHA Clarifying Treatment Toner.
Tea tree is ingredient no. 15 in Heartleaf Skin Toner Pads and is not in the list for AHA/BHA Clarifying Treatment Toner.
PHA acids is ingredient no. 4 in Heartleaf Skin Toner Pads and is not in the list for AHA/BHA Clarifying Treatment Toner.
Amino acids is ingredient no. 5 in Heartleaf Skin Toner Pads and is not in the list for AHA/BHA Clarifying Treatment Toner.
Licorice root is ingredient no. 8 in Heartleaf Skin Toner Pads and is not in the list for AHA/BHA Clarifying Treatment Toner.
Verdict:Some things to note(Heartleaf Skin Toner Pads)Non-comedogenic(AHA/BHA Clarifying Treatment Toner)
Panthenol (B5) is ingredient no. 7 in Heartleaf Skin Toner Pads and no. 9 in AHA/BHA Clarifying Treatment Toner.
Salicylic acid (BHA) is ingredient no. 11 in Heartleaf Skin Toner Pads and no. 7 in AHA/BHA Clarifying Treatment Toner.
AHA acids is ingredient no. 12 in Heartleaf Skin Toner Pads and no. 6 in AHA/BHA Clarifying Treatment Toner.
The list for Heartleaf Skin Toner Pads has 26 ingredients; the list for AHA/BHA Clarifying Treatment Toner has 11 ingredients.
Side by side
Benton Heartleaf Skin Toner Pads and COSRX AHA/BHA Clarifying Treatment Toner side by side
Pairs follow a published formula: same category, both ingredient lists read and at least one price each, one of the two among its category's 50 cheapest or the 50 with prices from the most stores, and neither a set, gift box or mini size. The two share at least two key ingredients, or one and a price per 100 ml in the same range (the dearer at most 2.5 times the other). The most alike pairs come first.
Yes
Silicone-free
Yes
Yes
Sulfate-free
Yes
Yes
No watchlist ingredients
Yes
Yes
Cruelty-free
No information
No information
Vegan
No information
No information
Key ingredients
Houttuynia cordatano. 1, not counting water
PHA acidsno. 4, not counting water
Amino acidsno. 5, not counting water
Panthenol (B5)no. 7, not counting water
Licorice rootno. 8, not counting water
Salicylic acid (BHA)no. 11, not counting water
AHA acidsno. 12, not counting water
Hyaluronic acidno. 14, not counting water
Tea treeno. 15, not counting water
Madecassosideno. 22, not counting water
AHA acidsno. 6, not counting water
Salicylic acid (BHA)no. 7, not counting water
Panthenol (B5)no. 9, not counting water
Ingredients in the list
26 ingredients
11 ingredients
Prices by store
YesStyleCheapest£19.67 (about €23.41)Buy · YesStyleAffiliate link
Lyko€35.50Out of stock
YesStyleCheapest£10.06 (about €11.97)€7.98 / 100 mlBuy · YesStyleAffiliate link
The lowest price is in bold. Positions do not count water. Prices checked 10/21/2026.
Buy buttons are affiliate links: SkinIndex may earn a commission if you buy through them. The price is the same for you, and stores are listed by price. Affiliate disclosure
Heartleaf Skin Toner Pads vs AHA/BHA Clarifying Treatment Toner